Now that we have seen how the financial statements of a company are drawn up, let us try and learn to "read between the lines". While looking at the financials of a company, you must ask some important questions. Here are some for starters:
- If company posts a profit, does it mean that it is really doing well?
- How has the company suddenly posted such a huge profit this year after a dismal performance last time? Have sales really improved?
- Is the company's debt really as low as shown in the balance sheet?
- I see this section called Miscellaneous Expenses in the balance sheet. The problem is that this makes up for more that 15% of the assets. Is that a good thing or not?
Well, answers to these questions, and many many more such questions, are not obvious. Take a look at the questions again. Now here are a possible set of answers to them:
Accounting Profits
The profits posted by a company need not necessarily reflect the true state of affairs. Say for example, more than 40% of the net sales shown in the income statement is sold on a 90-day credit. The company will receive this money only in the future. (Even a 10-year-old will tell you that the future is unpredictable). So now you see? The profits that you see are in fact, expected profits- accounting profits, perhaps, is a better term to use here. So don't get carried away by the amount of profit unless you know that the company has sold goods on credit to people who are likely to actually pay up within time.
Sudden Spurt in Profits
The company has suddenly posted a huge profit. Wow! Sales must have improved tremendously. Three cheers to the management!!
Really??
Take a look at the income statement again. Do you see something called Non-Recurring Income? That could explain the sudden increase in profitability. Non-recurring income refers to income that is not expected to continue in future. They are one-time receipts that often do not arise out of regular business activities.
Maybe the management is actually selling off some of it's assets to maintain liquidity while you think that the company is going great guns.
Debt Off the Balance Sheet
You see that the company operates with very little debt. Just before you start believing what you see, take a look at the Notes to the balance sheet. Take a look at the section called Off-Balance Sheet Items. Off-balance sheet items could contain just about any liability that the company does not necessarily have to disclose upfront. Contingent liabilities (liabilities that might arise on the happening of a certain event in future), operating leases, letters of credit, futures, and forwards are some examples here.
So you see? These long list of liabilities don't eve appear in the balance sheet! So watch out before drawing any conclusions.
"Miscellaneous" Expenses
Miscellaneous expenses is another favourite section used by companies to keep things under wraps. This section of the balance sheet records various expenses that are incurred by the company but not written off against the profits they make. For example, the company recently issued debentures to the public at a discounted rate. The discount should ideally be written off against the profits earned. But the company can choose to carry them forward instead of adjusting them against their profits. This way, the company manages to post better profits. Unfair, isn't it?
We have discussed just four questions here. Believe me, there are hundreds of such questions to which you will not find straight forward answers.
So remember to take a nice hard look at the financials of the company before you decide whether the company is really faring well or not.